The America 250
Faith Gap
A survey of children's reading lists curated for America's 250th birthday — and what they collectively chose to leave out.
Reviewed
Surveyed
Addressing Faith
By submitting, you agree to receive email communications from BRAVE Books. Unsubscribe anytime.
Not one title. Not one source.
As the nation prepares to celebrate its 250th birthday on July 4, 2026, libraries, publishers, and educational institutions across America have curated reading lists to guide families toward books that tell children the story of their country's founding.
We surveyed every publicly available institutional list — spanning major publishers, public library systems, educational institutions, and government-affiliated programs — and cataloged more than 300 individual children's titles recommended for the occasion.
Not a single title on any list addresses faith, religious liberty, or Christianity's role in the founding of the United States. Not one title. Not one source.
Religious liberty is the first freedom named in the First Amendment. The Pilgrims came to this continent seeking freedom of worship. The Great Awakening helped forge a shared American identity across the colonies. Faith is not a footnote in the American story. It is foundational to it.
And yet, the institutions responsible for telling that story to the next generation have collectively decided to leave it out.
What institutions consider essential to the America 250 children's canon
The lists range from relatively traditional to explicitly progressive. But across the full sample, clear patterns emerge in what was considered worthy of inclusion.
LGBTQ+ History
Appears on multiple sources, including titles about trans women of color in LGBTQ+ history and Stonewall Riots survival stories.
Revisionist "Myth-Busting"
Appears on at least 10 sources. The most-listed single title in the survey carries the tagline: "Myths! Lies! Secrets!" One major publisher features an entire section called "Race to the Truth."
Native American Perspectives
Appears on the majority of sources, including titles framing colonization, Indigenous boarding schools, and land displacement.
Black History & Civil Rights
15.2% of all cataloged titles. Notably: no titles examine the Black church's role in American history, even on lists heavy with Black history content.
Faith: 0 titles
- No books about the Pilgrims as religious refugees
- No books about the Great Awakening
- No books about religious liberty as a founding principle
- No books about the faith lives of the founders
- No books about the Black church's role in American history — even on lists heavy with Black history content
- No books about faith-motivated abolitionists — even on lists featuring abolitionist narratives
- No titles from any faith-based publisher
When 300 books are curated for a nation's birthday and not one of them tells children about the role of faith in that nation's founding, something has been lost.
The editorial language reveals the posture behind the curation
The recurring vocabulary across these lists — "complicated," "complex," "voices long excluded," "hidden," "untold," "unfinished" — reveals a shared institutional assumption: the primary purpose of America's 250th birthday is to complicate, correct, or expand the traditional narrative. Celebration is qualified. Faith is omitted.
Introduces its list as books about "the rich, diverse, complicated history of the United States."
Promises to "spotlight protest and reform movements, voices long excluded from the history."
Notes that its picks "primarily feature one aspect of America's history — that of white colonists" and immediately redirects readers to "more voices and stories."
Titles its kids list "America at 250: Informational Books for Kids" — conspicuously avoiding the word "celebrate," which it uses freely on adjacent adult lists.
The complete findings, methodology, and source list.
Enter your email and we'll send you the full America 250 Faith Gap report — free.
By submitting, you agree to receive email communications from BRAVE Books. You can unsubscribe at any time.
Report on its way to your inbox
Check your email for the full America 250 Faith Gap report. While you're here — meet the books written to fill that gap.
Three signed books from Kirk Cameron, Dr. Ben Carson, and Riley Gaines — plus keepsakes that teach children why faith and freedom built this nation.
Show Your Support